Lionel Tate Sentenced to Life, Columnist Blathers About Childhood

Childhood’s End is one of the most disgusting articles I have ever read on Salon.com. Gary Kamiya declares that Friday was a day of shame in America. A child was sentenced to life in prison. That child was Lionel Tate, a 14 year old boy who viciously slammed 6 year old Tiffany Eunick into a wall and stomped and beat her until she died. He beat her until her ribs were broken, her abdomen was stomped so hard that it ripped a part of her liver off, and her head was split open, and he didn’t stop until she lay dead in pools of blood. But Kamiya thinks that in the face of this kind of utter depravity we need understanding that childhood, with its infinite complexities and sadnesses, is a universe that can’t always be described with words like coward and right and wrong.

Well, gee, bucko, I don’t give a good God damn about the infinite complexity or the sadness of childhood when it comes down to beating a little girl into a bloody pulp. And to describe his being led away to prison as a Taliban moment designed at gratifying the all-American imams in our midst is absolutely enraging. Look, I don’t believe in blood-punishment. I want humane sentencing and humane conditions in prison. And I find it incredibly offensive to imply that my motives are ugly vengeance simply because I recognize the fact Tate’s acts were shockingly, brutally, horrifyingly vicious, and invoking childhood is not any excuse for not protecting the rest of society from someone who would commit them. Tate has every right to humane conditions, psychiatric help and rehabilitation, a good education, and a safe space apart from adult offenders. In prison. For the rest of his natural life. You can sob all you want for the end of childhood in America, but you can NEVER put breaking the cookie jar and breaking a skull under the same exoneration of Childhood.

Advertisement

Help me get rid of these Google ads with a gift of $10.00 towards this month’s operating expenses for radgeek.com. See Donate for details.

15 replies to Lionel Tate Sentenced to Life, Columnist Blathers About Childhood Use a feed to Follow replies to this article · TrackBack URI

  1. amaris Brown

    well i think that trhe whole is just a mess children should be tried as adults they know what they are doing they know right from wrong.

· October 2003 ·

  1. Britt

    hE WAS ONLY 12.he didn’t know right from wrong.

· November 2003 ·

  1. Discussed at www.radgeek.com

    Geekery Today:

    Lionel Tate Sentencing Saga Continues, Faux Leftists Make Excuses for Murder

    The Lionel Tate sentencing saga continues, and I continue to be appalled by faux leftist outrage such as this…

  2. Discussed at www.radgeek.com

    Geekery Today:

    Lionel Tate May Be Transferred to Juvenile Facility

    Florida officials have announced that Lionel Tate may be transferred to juvenile facility, which is at least good news….

  3. alaric anastasia

    M. Mme. Lionel Tate a eu un jugement s�vere pour son age, que dans la guerre on donne l’ordre de tu�r des enfants en pretandant que ceci est accidentel et personne ne les juge parce qu’ils sont “puissants” .Et des tueurs en s�ries sont en libert� et continuent leurs crimes sans qu’ ils soient reprimand�s . Lionel Tate a comis un “crime” accidentel en ne se doutant pas du mal qu’il allait commettre.Chaque jour dans le monde des politiciens commettent des erreurs et prennent des actes sans demander l’avis du peuple qui est le principal delegataire de la souverainnet� et decident des guerre ou ils mettent en peril la vie de milliers d’hommes. aujourd’hui des millions d’hommes sont en prison pour rien !Honte a tous ceux qui ont fait rentrer Lionel Tate en prison et qui l’ont comdamn� comme un adulte qui aurait commis le double de son crime . jJ’ai envoy� plusieurs lettres ainsi que des petitions destin�es a m.george b. mais je n’ai jamais eu de nouvelle .merci de votre attention!

· December 2003 ·

  1. Meagan

    I think that it was part his fault and part his parents fault because his mother was sleeping in the other room. How can she not hear all the screaming and all the crying that the little girl was in. The it was his fault because they shouldn’t of been in the same room with each other playing around or doing whatever that he was doing to her. His mother should of been with them because if she was with them this wouldn’t of happened.

  2. Ms. McLarnon

    We are 7th and 8th grade students in st. lucy’s school “academy” in the Bronx. Our assignment is to try to understand the societal impact that the Lionel Tate case has on all of us. We are especially interested in the case as we are approximately the same age as Lionel Tate when he was convicted for this crime.We are going to write a detailed analysis about this case and then we will send it to you.

  3. Cassie

    My class and I are looking up the Lionel Tate Case. I realized that yes, he did wrong in killing the girl. Yea it doesn’t look like it was a game. But he did have pass problems, for the pass 8 years. His mother never really looked in getting him help for him and now that he wild out on the little 6 year old girl his getting life Sentence, that is just wrong…

  4. Cassie & Meagan

    Since our class is in the process of studing the Lionel tate Case. I Cassie and me Meagan are going to do a like kind of debate on the situation. Cassie will Be defending the defendent which is Lionel, and me Meagan will be defening the plantif which is tiffany.

  5. Cassie & Meagan

    Since our class is in the process of studing the Lionel tate Case. I Cassie and me Meagan are going to do a like kind of debate on the situation. Cassie will Be defending the defendent which is Lionel, and me Meagan will be defening the plantif which is tiffany. Muchazzzzzz….

  6. Cassie & Meagan

    Since our class is in the process of studing the Lionel tate Case. I Cassie and me Meagan are going to do a like kind of debate on the situation. Cassie will Be defending the defendent which is Lionel, and me Meagan will be defening the plantif which is tiffany. Muchazzzzzz….

  7. dikstr

    Tate should be incarcerated until he’s no longer capable of hurting another human being. Didn’t know right from wrong? The wrongness of killing a little girl doesn’t take a genius or education to understand. If Tate is too dumb to get that concept it is even more important that we keep him out of society forever!

  8. Norma

    I wholeheartedly agree with your comments about the Childhood’s end article. Murder is murder no matter how young the person is. We have to stop making excuses and blaming everything on everyone else, his mother, too much television, not enough attention, etc. He committed a crime, take responsibility for your action. He deserves life in prison.

— 2006 —

  1. Jim Turner

    Well you didn’t get your wish about the life imprisonment, but justice did finally have its day. Tate was just sentenced to 30 years for having a gun.

— 2008 —

  1. scineram

    It was about time. Who knows what has he done since.

Post a reply

By:
Your e-mail address will not be published.
You can register for an account and sign in to verify your identity and avoid spam traps.
Reply

Use Markdown syntax for formatting. *emphasis* = emphasis, **strong** = strong, [link](http://xyz.com) = link,
> block quote to quote blocks of text.

This form is for public comments. Consult About: Comments for policies and copyright details.