There’s no real way to reply seriously to the kind of deliberate political sadism suggested by nativist creeps like those commenting on Wizbang’s latest on the Evil Alien Invasion. So, instead, I’ll limit myself to a couple questions and a remark. Here’s
Linoge, suggesting massive new layers of government regulation in order to make undocumented immigrants suffer as much as it’s feasible to make them:
The wordillegalsums it up entirely… I would not go so far as to say they should be arrested on sight (though I am close), but their presence illegally in another nation should be heavily discouraged. That means, no health care, no driver’s licenses, no jobs, no nothing. At all. Ever. —Linoge
Well, at least you’re not going so far as to say they should be arrested on sight. That’s mighty white of you.
Now, here’s the question for the day. How would immigration cops looking to make an arrest determine somebody’s immigration status
on sight in the first place?
Meanwhile, here’s a small-government conservative who’s a fan of the East Berlin immigration policy:
At any rate, I don’t see why the States don’t take matters into their own hands. Why do we have to wait for the feds to take action? Is there some reason that Texas, New Mexico, Arizona and California can’t start building walls and fences along their borders with Mexico? What prevents the States from using their state police forces to find, arrest and detain for later deportation illegal aliens? I’m not suggesting roadblocks, house-to-house searches, orIhre Papiere, bitte, but I don’t see why a state trooper who stops a Hispanic driver can’t do a quick computer check to see if the person is in the country legally.
Here’s the second question for the day: what is the difference, if any, between (1) a cop stopping you and — solely on the basis of your race, by the way — demanding your ID for a check of your immigration status, and (2) a uniformed goon demanding
Ihre Papiere, bitte? Because he, what … demands your papers in English rather than in German?
SJBill, for his part, didn’t feel
threatened by undocumented Mexican immigrants until they scared him by … exercised freedom of speech and assembly:
Before these protests, I was pretty ambivalent on the issue — meaning I wasn’t directlythreatenedby illegal Mexicans. I see them all the time at local Home Depots, etc., but they are looking for work and trying to grind out a living. So, with the protests, thelights in the kitchen came onand we see millions of Mexicans (presuming most have other than legal status) marching in our cities and streets — all of a sudden I’m not quite so comfy. It’s pretty scary.
… I see a credible threat to our nation’s security, and we should do what we can to send these folks back home if they cannot abide the law of our land. That’s not being a xenophobe.
Maybe not. But suggesting that people be threatened, beaten, restrained, arrested,
detained, imprisoned, exiled, etc. simply on the basis of their nationality, for having done nothing more than tried to work for a living for a willing employer, is.